Pleasure-Centered Eating – Why It Feels So Good!

Nov 1, 2021 | Mind & Body

A few years ago Penina Taylor (Founder and Editor-In-Chief of UNORTHOBOXED) delivered a tantalizing talk entitled “How Do You Know God Loves You?” She challenged the audience to figure it out. After a few minutes, she responded to their collective guessing by exclaiming, “NOPE! The answer is…..CHOCOLATE!” And the audience broke out in an uproar of laughter! 

“Yep, chocolate!”  She then went on to explain how the pleasure it provides is a reminder that God loves us. Hashem did not have to create us with the ability to receive pleasure from the food we eat (or any of our senses, actually). But It is the very fact that we do experience pleasure that is proof that He loves us.

We don’t only receive pleasure from eating sweet foods, though. In addition to the taste of sweet, we can also discern salty, acidy, savory, spicy and “fatty” flavors. These tastes, in combination with the olfactory bulb which gives us our sense of smell, engage our limbic system in the brain and set off a chain reaction of neurotransmitters that stimulate the release of chemicals, that in turn signals the body to react to the message. 

The limbic system is made up of many important organs, including something called the amygdala as well as the nucleus accumbens, also known as “The Pleasure Center”.

This same complex limbic system stimulates memory and rapid reaction emotions, such as the fear “fight, flight or freeze’‘ response. It is also responsible for aggressive and violent reflexivity. But it is equally responsible for empathy and compassion. 

Daniel Goleman, an American psychologist and science journalist, is the author of the best-selling book Emotional Intelligence. In it, he calls this rapid response an amygdala hijack. “Emotions make us pay attention right now – this is urgent – and give us an immediate action plan without having to think twice. The emotional component evolved very early: Do I eat it, or does it eat me?” 

The amygdala’s primary job is our survival, and it evaluates our experiences to decide if they threaten our survival, or promote it.  If something threatens our survival, the amygdala gets us as far away from it as possible; but if it promotes it, we receive the signal to continue towards it. When we experience pleasure, our amygdala says, “This is good, do it again.”

It follows then that the amygdala would create an appetite for anything that gives us pleasure and is therefore interpreted as being survival-promoting. 

We can see that Penina’s assertion on the pleasure factor is definitely backed by science.

The discovery of the pleasure center, some technical info

The “pleasure center” of the brain was co-discovered in 1954 by James Olds, an American psychologist, and Peter Milner who was a postdoctoral fellow at McGill University. Olds and Milner stumbled on the pleasure center after they implanted electrodes into the septal area of the rat and found that rats became addicted to pushing a lever that was stimulating the nucleus accumbens (NAcc).

Electrical stimulation triggers the release of dopamine in the NAcc, much in the same way that addictive drugs and natural reinforcers, such as sex, drugs, alcohol, food, extreme sports—or anything pleasurable—also trigger the release of dopamine in the nucleus accumbens.

The rats in Olds and Milner’s experiment would continue to press this lever incessantly even at the expense of eating and drinking for sustenance. This suggests that the area is the “pleasure center” of the brain and is involved in the reward-driven reinforcement of learning and addiction.  (Christopher Bergland, The Athlete’s Way

The same results have been seen in human subjects, in brain imaging studies called Optogenetics, using light-responsive proteins to “light up” the areas of the brain during stimulation.  

So what happens in the pleasure center (nucleus accumbens – NAcc) when we eat refined sugar and high fat, and why are they so addicting?

Using Penina’s example, chocolate contains over five hundred chemicals. Some of these chemicals are endorphins – the feel-good (and addictive) properties. They include:

Phenylethylamine (PEA) – (similar to dopamine and adrenaline)

  • Caffeine – energy stimulus
  • Tryptophan – soothing, relaxing effect, sleep enhancer
  • Anandamidea fatty acid neurotransmitter. It was the first endocannabinoid to be discovered: it participates in the body’s cannabinoid system by binding to cannabinoid receptors, the same receptors that the psychoactive compound THC in cannabis acts on. The name ‘anandamide’ is taken from the 

Sanskrit word ananda, which means “joy, bliss, and delight”. 

When those delicious food morsels containing sugar and fat, with their high glycemic indexes, hit our taste buds, an electrical stimulation triggers a cascade release of endorphins in the brain. Result: we feel very good, unless we eat too much, then the chemical overload can have a negative effect and we don’t really feel so good after all. But, the addictive properties (and our memories of good feelings) keep us coming back for more, just like the lab rats. And this can lead to physical and emotional ill health, including obesity. 

When refined sugars (very high glycemic index – energy molecules) combine with high fat (high glycemic index, also energy molecules) in things like yummy cakes, donuts, cookies, milkshakes and ice cream, et al, the effects are compounded exponentially and stimulate a very large insulin response. Larger than just one carbohydrate stimulant alone. The unused, and currently unneeded, energy created by the compound gets stored as fat reserves. This is one of several contributing factors (in addition to the excess calories) that increase the risk of developing insulin resistance (type 2 diabetes). There are other risk potentials as well. Elevated cholesterol levels can lead to heart disease, kidney dysfunction, high blood pressure, to name just a few.   

We push the limits, enduring pain of sports, drug abuse, attention-seeking behaviors, overeating and yes, even the joys and labors of pregnancies, all for the sublime benefit of the pleasure received. To experience the release of endorphins, dopamine and adrenaline, among others, all for the ultimate “Feel Good” experience.

I’m ready for a nice large mug of hot chocolate with coffee, a scoop of vanilla ice cream with a dash or two of shaved cinnamon, topped with luscious whipped cream drizzled with hot chocolate syrup and finished with a spoonful of candy sprinkles. – Yes, but…. 

“Everything is allowed, but not everything is beneficial”.

And everything in life is a choice. The free will that Hashem has instilled in us calls for the appropriate response by us. Is this beneficial or detrimental to me?  

Related Articles

Related